Westchester Independent Living Center, Inc.
   
 
 
 
 

Reasonable Accommodation

  • Reasonable Accommodations are

    changes in rules, policies, or services so that a person with a disability may have an equal opportunity to use and enjoy the housing.


  • The change must be practical and do-able.

  • YOU must ask for it.

The landlord or manager cannot refuse because,
"It's always been done this way."

But, the landlord may ask for proof of the need for the accommodation.

Examples of Reasonable Accommodations:

  • Changing a "no pets" rule to allow a companion dog for someone with a psychi

    atric disability.
  • Providing notices to tenants in large print.

  • Keeping a laundry room door closed so that fumes do not make someone who is chemically sensitive ill.

Building or Apartment Modifications

  • You have the right to make reasonable modifications to your housing or common areas, such as lobbies, main entrance, or laundry room

    at your expense* - if they are necessary for full use of your housing.

    *In housing covered by Section 504 of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act it is the owner's responsibility to pay for reasonable modifications.

  • The landlord has the right

    to condition permission for the modification based on assurance that work will be done properly,

    to ask you to obtain any necessary building permits,

    to ask you to agree to restore your unit, but not common use areas, after you leave unless it is not reasonable to do so (as in narrowing a doorway you have widened), and

    to ask you to set aside a reasonable amount of money over a reasonable time in an interest bearing escrow account to pay for restoration.

Examples of Modifications

  • Lowering cabinets to a height usable by someone in a wheelchair.

  • Installing grab bars in the bathroom when someone has limited mobility.

  • Changing the door handles (to levered handles) and lessening the opening pressure on the building's main entrance door when arthritis would make it otherwise difficult to open the door.
-

Reasonable Accommodations

The FHAA requires two (2) types of reasonable accommodations to make existing housing more accessible to persons with disabilities. These accommodations consist of (A) Structural Modifications and (B) Policy Changes.

(A) Structural Modifications

Housing providers must permit reasonable modifications of existing premises if such modifications are necessary for a person with a disability to be able to live in and use the premises. The cost of the modification is to be paid by the resident with a disability.

Modifications may be made to the interior of the individual's unit, as well as any public and common use areas of a building, including lobbies, hallways, and laundry rooms.

Modifications may be requested in any type of dwelling, however, in a rental situation the landlord may reasonably condition permission for modification on the following:

  • The renter agreeing to restore the interior of the premises to the condition that existed before the modification, ordinary wear and tear excepted;
  • The renter providing a reasonable description of the proposed modifications; and
  • The renter providing reasonable assurance that the work will be done in a workmanlike manner with all applicable building permits being obtained.

A renter should be aware that a landlord must not increase any customarily required security deposit. However, where it is necessary to ensure with reasonable certainty that funds will be available for any necessary restoration at the end of the tenancy, the landlord may require that the tenant pay a reasonable amount of money, not to exceed the cost of the restorations, into an interest bearing escrow account over a reasonable period of time. The interest earned on the account accrues to the benefit of the tenant. This means that when the tenant with a disability moves and the unit is restored to its original condition any money left in the account is given to the tenant.

As a result of these rules, the FHAA has, in effect, created three (3) classifications of modifications:

  1. Modifications that do not have to be restored;
  2. Modifications that need to be restored to the original condition, but do not require establishment of an escrow account; and
  3. Modifications that need to be restored and are relatively expensive, therefore an escrow account may be required.

An example of the first modification category would be widening a bathroom door, which does not affect the usability of any other space, such as a closet. Here a wider door would not affect the next tenant's use of the apartment.

An example of the second modification category would be the removal of a base cabinet under the kitchen sink. In this situation, the next tenant would want the storage space under the sink. Therefore, the tenant with a disability would be required to restore the cabinet. The cost to replace one cabinet would not be tremendous, so an escrow account would probably not be required.

If all the cabinets in the kitchen were replaced and the counter lowered, which is obviously more expensive, an escrow account may be required - making this an example of the third modification category. A traditional example of a situation where an escrow account may be needed is when a tenant removes the bathtub and replaces it with a roll-in shower.

Remember, although a landlord may condition permission, he/she cannot deny permission for modifications needed so that the tenant with a disability can use and enjoy his/her home.

(B) Policy Changes

The FHAA requires that the housing provider make reasonable modifications in rules, policies, practices or services necessary to give persons with disabilities equal opportunity to use and enjoy the dwelling. Examples of modifications that would be required include:

  • Allowing a tenant who is blind to have a guide dog even though the building has a no pet policy. This same rule would apply to individuals who need a service animal, emotional support animal or a therapy animal.
  • Reserving a parking space for a tenant with a mobility impairment that is accessible and close to an accessible route when other tenants must park on a first come, first served basis.
  • Waiving a rule that allows only tenants to use laundry facilities in order to accommodate a tenant with a disability who cannot gain access to the laundry facilities by allowing his/her friend or aide to do the laundry.

In short, any policy or rule that denies people with disabilities access to a facility or service may be a violation of FHAA.


 
 Home
 Newsletters
 PutnamILS.org
 ILUSA.com
 Parent TIP.org
 NYSILC.org
 ILNY.org
 Espanol
 SiteMap